Nucleation

Overview

Nucleation is the process by which gas-phase molecules spontaneously form small clusters (nuclei) that can grow into aerosol particles. This module implements classical nucleation theory for single-component (homogeneous) nucleation following the treatment in Seinfeld & Pandis (2006), Chapter 11.

The key outputs of the nucleation model are:

  • Critical cluster size (i*): The minimum number of molecules required for a stable cluster
  • Critical radius (r*): The radius of the critical cluster
  • Nucleation rate (J): The rate at which new particles form per unit volume per unit time
  • Free energy barrier (ΔG*): The energy barrier that must be overcome for nucleation to occur

Reference: Seinfeld, J.H. and Pandis, S.N. (2006). Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics: From Air Pollution to Climate Change, 2nd Edition, Chapter 11, pp. 489-536.

Aerosol.Nucleation — Function
Nucleation(; name=:Nucleation)

A component representing homogeneous nucleation of a single-component vapor following classical nucleation theory from Seinfeld & Pandis (2006), Chapter 11.

This component calculates the nucleation rate, critical cluster size, and critical radius based on the saturation ratio, temperature, and species properties.

Variables

  • S: Saturation ratio (dimensionless), ratio of partial pressure to saturation vapor pressure
  • J: Nucleation rate (molecules/(m³·s))
  • i_star: Critical cluster size (molecules)
  • r_star: Critical cluster radius (m)
  • ΔG_star: Free energy barrier (J)
  • θ: Dimensionless surface tension parameter

Parameters

  • T: Temperature (K)
  • p_A: Partial pressure of condensing species (Pa)
  • p_A_s: Saturation vapor pressure (Pa)
  • σ: Surface tension (N/m)
  • v_1: Molecular volume (m³/molecule)
  • m_1: Molecular mass (kg/molecule)

References

Seinfeld, J.H. and Pandis, S.N. (2006). Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics: From Air Pollution to Climate Change, 2nd Edition, Chapter 11, pp. 489-536.

source
Aerosol.CriticalCluster — Function
CriticalCluster(; name=:CriticalCluster)

A standalone component for computing critical cluster properties without the full nucleation rate calculation. Useful for parameter sensitivity studies.

This implements equations 11.35, 11.52, and 11.53 from Seinfeld & Pandis (2006).

Variables

  • i_star: Critical cluster size (molecules)
  • r_star: Critical cluster radius (m)
  • ΔG_star: Free energy barrier (J)
  • θ: Dimensionless surface tension parameter

Parameters

  • T: Temperature (K)
  • S: Saturation ratio
  • σ: Surface tension (N/m)
  • v_1: Molecular volume (m³/molecule)
source
Aerosol.ClassicalNucleationRate — Function
ClassicalNucleationRate(; name=:ClassicalNucleationRate)

A simplified component that computes only the classical nucleation rate (Eq. 11.47) from Seinfeld & Pandis (2006). This is a minimal component for use when critical cluster properties are not needed.

Variables

  • J: Nucleation rate (molecules/(m³·s))

Parameters

  • T: Temperature (K)
  • S: Saturation ratio
  • N_1: Monomer number concentration (molecules/m³)
  • σ: Surface tension (N/m)
  • v_1: Molecular volume (m³/molecule)
  • m_1: Molecular mass (kg/molecule)
source
Aerosol.WaterProperties — Function
WaterProperties(; name=:WaterProperties)

A component providing temperature-dependent physical properties of water for nucleation calculations following the data from Seinfeld & Pandis (2006), Table 11.1 and 11.4.

Variables

  • σ: Surface tension (N/m)
  • v_1: Molecular volume (m³/molecule)
  • m_1: Molecular mass (kg/molecule)
  • p_sat: Saturation vapor pressure (Pa)

Parameters

  • T: Temperature (K)

References

Seinfeld, J.H. and Pandis, S.N. (2006). Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, Chapter 11.

source

Implementation

The implementation follows classical nucleation theory, which treats the formation of molecular clusters using thermodynamic arguments. The key assumption is the capillarity approximation: clusters of all sizes are assumed to have the same surface tension as bulk liquid.

State Variables

using DataFrames, ModelingToolkit, Symbolics, DynamicQuantities
using Aerosol
using OrdinaryDiffEq
using Plots

sys = Nucleation()
vars = unknowns(sys)
DataFrame(
    :Name => [string(Symbolics.tosymbol(v, escape = false)) for v in vars],
    :Units => [ModelingToolkit.get_unit(v) for v in vars],
    :Description => [ModelingToolkit.getdescription(v) for v in vars]
)
8×3 DataFrame
RowNameUnitsDescription
StringQuantity…String
1S1.0 Saturation ratio (dimensionless)
2N_11.0 m⁻³Monomer number concentration
3a_11.0 m²Monomer surface area
4θ1.0 Dimensionless surface tension (dimensionless)
5i_star1.0 Critical cluster size (dimensionless)
6r_star1.0 mCritical cluster radius
7ΔG_star1.0 m² kg s⁻²Free energy barrier
8J1.0 m⁻³ s⁻¹Nucleation rate

Parameters

pars = parameters(sys)
DataFrame(
    :Name => [string(Symbolics.tosymbol(p, escape = false)) for p in pars],
    :Units => [ModelingToolkit.get_unit(p) for p in pars],
    :Description => [ModelingToolkit.getdescription(p) for p in pars]
)
8×3 DataFrame
RowNameUnitsDescription
StringQuantity…String
1p_A1.0 m⁻¹ kg s⁻²Partial pressure of condensing species
2p_A_s1.0 m⁻¹ kg s⁻²Saturation vapor pressure
3T1.0 KTemperature
4k_B1.0 m² kg s⁻² K⁻¹Boltzmann constant
5π_val1.0 Pi (dimensionless)
6v_11.0 m³Molecular volume
7σ1.0 kg s⁻²Surface tension
8m_11.0 kgMolecular mass

Equations

The system implements the following equations from Seinfeld & Pandis (2006):

eqs = equations(sys)
8-element Vector{Symbolics.Equation}:
 S(t) ~ p_A / p_A_s
 N_1(t) ~ p_A / (T*k_B)
 a_1(t) ~ 4(((3v_1) / (4π_val))^(2//3))*π_val
 θ(t) ~ (3.3019272488946263(v_1^(2//3))*(π_val^(1//3))*σ) / (T*k_B)
 i_star(t) ~ ((2θ(t)) / (3log(S(t))))^3
 r_star(t) ~ (2v_1*σ) / (T*k_B*log(S(t)))
 ΔG_star(t) ~ (16(v_1^2)*π_val*(σ^3)) / (3(T^2)*(k_B^2)*(log(S(t))^2))
 J(t) ~ ((N_1(t)^2)*exp((-16(v_1^2)*π_val*(σ^3)) / (3(T^3)*(k_B^3)*(log(S(t))^2)))*sqrt((2σ) / (m_1*π_val))*v_1) / S(t)

Core Equations

The saturation ratio (Eq. 11.1) is the ratio of partial pressure to saturation vapor pressure:

\[S = \frac{p_A}{p_A^s(T)}\]

The critical cluster size (Eq. 11.35) is determined by the competition between bulk and surface terms:

\[i^* = \left(\frac{2\theta}{3\ln S}\right)^3\]

where θ is the dimensionless surface tension parameter (Eq. 11.27):

\[\theta = \frac{(36\pi)^{1/3} v_1^{2/3} \sigma}{k_B T}\]

The critical radius (Eq. 11.52) follows from the Kelvin equation:

\[r^* = \frac{2\sigma v_1}{k_B T \ln S}\]

The free energy barrier (Eq. 11.53) is:

\[\Delta G^* = \frac{16\pi}{3} \frac{v_1^2 \sigma^3}{(k_B T \ln S)^2}\]

The classical nucleation rate (Eq. 11.47) gives the rate of new particle formation:

\[J = \sqrt{\frac{2\sigma}{\pi m_1}} \frac{v_1 N_1^2}{S} \exp\left(-\frac{16\pi}{3} \frac{v_1^2 \sigma^3}{(k_B T)^3 (\ln S)^2}\right)\]

Analysis

Validation Against Table 11.1: Critical Cluster Properties for Water

The following analysis reproduces Table 11.1 from Seinfeld & Pandis (2006), showing critical cluster properties for water at 273 K and 298 K.

using OrdinaryDiffEq

# Water properties from Table 11.1
σ_273 = 75.6e-3  # N/m at 273 K
σ_298 = 72.0e-3  # N/m at 298 K
v_1 = 2.99e-29   # m³/molecule

sys = CriticalCluster()
compiled = mtkcompile(sys)

# Calculate for 273 K
results_273 = []
for S in [2, 3, 4, 5]
    prob = ODEProblem(compiled,
        Dict(
            compiled.T => 273.0,
            compiled.S => Float64(S),
            compiled.σ => σ_273,
            compiled.v_1 => v_1
        ),
        (0.0, 1.0))
    sol = solve(prob, Tsit5())
    r_star_angstrom = sol[compiled.r_star][1] * 1e10  # Convert to Å
    i_star = sol[compiled.i_star][1]
    push!(results_273, (
        S = S, r_star = round(r_star_angstrom, digits = 1), i_star = round(Int, i_star)))
end

# Calculate for 298 K
results_298 = []
for S in [2, 3, 4, 5]
    prob = ODEProblem(compiled,
        Dict(
            compiled.T => 298.0,
            compiled.S => Float64(S),
            compiled.σ => σ_298,
            compiled.v_1 => v_1
        ),
        (0.0, 1.0))
    sol = solve(prob, Tsit5())
    r_star_angstrom = sol[compiled.r_star][1] * 1e10
    i_star = sol[compiled.i_star][1]
    push!(results_298, (
        S = S, r_star = round(r_star_angstrom, digits = 1), i_star = round(Int, i_star)))
end

# Display results as a table
println("Table 11.1: Critical Number and Radius for Water Droplets")
println("="^70)
println("        T = 273 K                    T = 298 K")
println("S    r* (Å)    i*                r* (Å)    i*")
println("-"^70)
for (r273, r298) in zip(results_273, results_298)
    println("$(r273.S)    $(r273.r_star)       $(r273.i_star)                 $(r298.r_star)       $(r298.i_star)")
end

# Expected values from Table 11.1
println("\nExpected values from Seinfeld & Pandis Table 11.1:")
println("T=273K: S=2: r*=17.3Å, i*=726; S=3: r*=10.9Å, i*=182; S=4: r*=8.7Å, i*=87; S=5: r*=7.5Å, i*=58")
println("T=298K: S=2: r*=15.1Å, i*=482; S=3: r*=9.5Å, i*=121; S=4: r*=7.6Å, i*=60; S=5: r*=6.5Å, i*=39")
Table 11.1: Critical Number and Radius for Water Droplets
======================================================================
        T = 273 K                    T = 298 K
S    r* (Å)    i*                r* (Å)    i*
----------------------------------------------------------------------
2    17.3       726                 15.1       482
3    10.9       182                 9.5       121
4    8.7       91                 7.5       60
5    7.5       58                 6.5       39

Expected values from Seinfeld & Pandis Table 11.1:
T=273K: S=2: r*=17.3Å, i*=726; S=3: r*=10.9Å, i*=182; S=4: r*=8.7Å, i*=87; S=5: r*=7.5Å, i*=58
T=298K: S=2: r*=15.1Å, i*=482; S=3: r*=9.5Å, i*=121; S=4: r*=7.6Å, i*=60; S=5: r*=6.5Å, i*=39

Validation Against Table 11.4: Nucleation Rates for Water

This reproduces Table 11.4 from Seinfeld & Pandis (2006), showing nucleation rates for water at 293 K.

# Water properties at 293 K from Table 11.4
σ_293 = 72.75e-3      # N/m
v_1 = 2.99e-29        # m³/molecule
m_1 = 2.99e-26        # kg/molecule
p_sat_293 = 2336.5    # Pa

sys = Nucleation()
compiled = mtkcompile(sys)

println("Table 11.4: Homogeneous Nucleation Rate and Critical Cluster Size for Water at T = 293 K")
println("="^80)
println("S      i*      J (cm⁻³s⁻¹)           Expected J")
println("-"^80)

expected_J = Dict(2 => 5.02e-54, 3 => 1.76e-6, 4 => 1.05e6, 5 => 1.57e11,
    6 => 1.24e14, 7 => 8.99e15, 8 => 1.79e17, 9 => 1.65e18, 10 => 9.17e18)

for S in [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10]
    prob = ODEProblem(compiled,
        Dict(
            compiled.T => 293.0,
            compiled.p_A => Float64(S) * p_sat_293,
            compiled.p_A_s => p_sat_293,
            compiled.σ => σ_293,
            compiled.v_1 => v_1,
            compiled.m_1 => m_1
        ),
        (0.0, 1.0))
    sol = solve(prob, Tsit5())
    J = sol[compiled.J][1] * 1e-6  # Convert from m⁻³s⁻¹ to cm⁻³s⁻¹
    i_star = sol[compiled.i_star][1]
    println("$(S)      $(round(Int, i_star))      $(round(J, sigdigits=3))           $(expected_J[S])")
end
Table 11.4: Homogeneous Nucleation Rate and Critical Cluster Size for Water at T = 293 K
================================================================================
S      i*      J (cm⁻³s⁻¹)           Expected J
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2      523      4.38e-54           5.02e-54
3      131      1.66e-6           1.76e-6
4      65      1.02e6           1.05e6
5      42      1.53e11           1.57e11
6      30      1.22e14           1.24e14
7      24      8.84e15           8.99e15
8      19      1.76e17           1.79e17
9      16      1.62e18           1.65e18
10      14      9.06e18           9.17e18

Figure: Critical Cluster Size vs. Saturation Ratio

This figure shows how the critical cluster size decreases with increasing saturation ratio, demonstrating why nucleation "switches on" sharply at a threshold supersaturation.

using Plots

S_range = 1.5:0.1:10.0
i_stars = Float64[]
r_stars = Float64[]

sys = CriticalCluster()
compiled = mtkcompile(sys)

for S in S_range
    prob = ODEProblem(compiled,
        Dict(
            compiled.T => 293.0,
            compiled.S => S,
            compiled.σ => 72.75e-3,
            compiled.v_1 => 2.99e-29
        ),
        (0.0, 1.0))
    sol = solve(prob, Tsit5())
    push!(i_stars, sol[compiled.i_star][1])
    push!(r_stars, sol[compiled.r_star][1] * 1e10)  # Convert to Å
end

p1 = plot(
    S_range, i_stars, xlabel = "Saturation Ratio S", ylabel = "Critical Cluster Size i*",
    label = "i*", lw = 2, legend = :topright, yscale = :log10,
    title = "Critical Cluster Size vs. Saturation Ratio (T=293K)")

p2 = plot(
    S_range, r_stars, xlabel = "Saturation Ratio S", ylabel = "Critical Radius r* (Å)",
    label = "r*", lw = 2, legend = :topright,
    title = "Critical Radius vs. Saturation Ratio (T=293K)")

plot(p1, p2, layout = (1, 2), size = (900, 400))
Example block output

Figure: Nucleation Rate vs. Saturation Ratio (analogous to Table 11.4)

This figure illustrates the extreme sensitivity of nucleation rate to saturation ratio.

S_range = 2.0:0.5:10.0
J_rates = Float64[]

sys = Nucleation()
compiled = mtkcompile(sys)

for S in S_range
    prob = ODEProblem(compiled,
        Dict(
            compiled.T => 293.0,
            compiled.p_A => S * 2336.5,
            compiled.p_A_s => 2336.5,
            compiled.σ => 72.75e-3,
            compiled.v_1 => 2.99e-29,
            compiled.m_1 => 2.99e-26
        ),
        (0.0, 1.0))
    sol = solve(prob, Tsit5())
    J = sol[compiled.J][1] * 1e-6  # Convert to cm⁻³s⁻¹
    push!(J_rates, max(J, 1e-60))  # Floor at 1e-60 for log scale
end

plot(
    S_range, J_rates, xlabel = "Saturation Ratio S", ylabel = "Nucleation Rate J (cm⁻³s⁻¹)",
    label = "J", lw = 2, yscale = :log10,
    title = "Classical Nucleation Rate vs. Saturation Ratio (Water at 293K)",
    ylims = (1e-60, 1e25), legend = :bottomright)
Example block output

Temperature Dependence of Critical Properties

This analysis shows how temperature affects critical cluster properties at a fixed saturation ratio.

T_range = 250.0:5.0:320.0
S = 4.0

i_stars_T = Float64[]
r_stars_T = Float64[]

# Approximate temperature-dependent surface tension: σ ≈ 75.6 - 0.1454*(T-273) mN/m
σ_func(T) = (75.6 - 0.1454 * (T - 273)) * 1e-3

sys = CriticalCluster()
compiled = mtkcompile(sys)

for T in T_range
    prob = ODEProblem(compiled,
        Dict(
            compiled.T => T,
            compiled.S => S,
            compiled.σ => σ_func(T),
            compiled.v_1 => 2.99e-29
        ),
        (0.0, 1.0))
    sol = solve(prob, Tsit5())
    push!(i_stars_T, sol[compiled.i_star][1])
    push!(r_stars_T, sol[compiled.r_star][1] * 1e10)
end

p1 = plot(
    T_range, i_stars_T, xlabel = "Temperature (K)", ylabel = "Critical Cluster Size i*",
    label = "i*", lw = 2, title = "Critical Cluster Size vs. Temperature (S=4)")

p2 = plot(
    T_range, r_stars_T, xlabel = "Temperature (K)", ylabel = "Critical Radius r* (Å)",
    label = "r*", lw = 2, title = "Critical Radius vs. Temperature (S=4)")

plot(p1, p2, layout = (1, 2), size = (900, 400))
Example block output

Key Behaviors

Saturation Ratio Dependence

The nucleation rate is extremely sensitive to the saturation ratio S:

  • At S < 2, nucleation is essentially zero for atmospheric conditions
  • The transition from negligible to significant nucleation occurs over a narrow range of S
  • At high S (> 5), the rate increases by many orders of magnitude per unit increase in S

Temperature Dependence

Temperature affects nucleation through multiple pathways:

  • Higher T reduces the free energy barrier, increasing J
  • Higher T increases vapor pressure, affecting S
  • Surface tension typically decreases with T

Critical Cluster Size

The critical cluster size i* decreases with increasing S:

  • At low S, very large clusters are needed before they become stable
  • At high S, even small clusters can grow spontaneously
  • This explains why nucleation "switches on" sharply at a threshold S

Limitations

  1. Capillarity approximation: The model assumes clusters of all sizes have bulk liquid surface tension, which becomes inaccurate for small clusters (i* < 20-30).

  2. Single-component only: This implementation covers homogeneous single-component nucleation. Binary nucleation (e.g., H₂SO₄-H₂O) requires additional equations not yet implemented.

  3. Steady-state assumption: The classical nucleation rate assumes the cluster distribution has reached steady state.

  4. No kinetic effects: The model does not account for non-equilibrium effects or condensation/evaporation kinetics beyond the equilibrium rate constants.